Episode 1
Hemlock and Death of Socrates

Written by: Mitch Tucker
E-mail me at: mlt57@ou.edu
Project Home
Episode 2: Medieval Medical Treatments
Episode3: Early Modern Hemlock

Death of Socrates
"The Death of Socrates" by Jacques-Louis David(1787)


    Hemlock, also known as Conium maculatum, is one of the most recognized herbal botanicals in ancient medicine. Ancient populations were very aware of hemlock and its poisonous nature[5]. Its uses ranged from curing aching joints and symptoms similar to arthritis to being used in lethal amounts to carry out the execution of prisoners. Hemlock is a tall vastly branched plant, sometimes growing up to 10 feet high, with lots of foliage and white flowers giving it an innocent appearance but it has a bitter taste and emits a very unpleasant odor when bruised[4]. The most toxic element of hemlock is coniine, which is a neurotoxin and wreaks havoc on the central nervous system. When used as a medicine hemlock has sedative characteristics along with antispasmodic properties but during the ancient time period Greek physicians used hemlock for a variety of ailments including joint pain[4]. A major issue with the use of hemlock during the ancient period was that it had to be used in extremely small doses and had to be used with extreme caution. The line between the hemlock helping and the hemlock killing was a very thin one. An overdose of hemlock could produce paralysis and eventually lead to death.
    The most famous death caused by hemlock and the name most closely associated with hemlock is Socrates. Socrates was a prominent philosopher who represented a shift in emphasis within Greek philosophy, away from cosmological concerns toward political and ethical matters[1]. Although Socrates was one of the most prominent philosophers of his time not a single work of his has survived. The majority of our knowledge on Socrates comes from the works of Plato who was an understudy of Socrates and wrote many commentaries about Socrates. Plato's work Phaedo describes the death of Socrates from the ingestion of Hemlock.
   
Socrates
Portrait of Socrates



    Imagine being one of the most highly regarded philosophers of your time period living in a time period where new discoveries and theories were happening everyday. You did not worry about how your reasoning and theories upset the leaders of your time; instead you were entirely devoted to finding the pure, unfiltered truth that you thought must be out there.Then suddenly the leaders of your time began to believe that you were corrupting the youth, while you were truly only there to teach them and allow them to come to a better understanding of the world around them. The leaders were so influential that they turned a whole town against you, even some of the pupils you had been teaching for years. I believe this is the type of thinking that Socrates employed as he delved deep into the political, moral, and legal matters of his time and then suddenly felt the hatred and ire of the town leaders. The questions he raised caused the leaders of the Athens to believe he was leading the youth of Athens astray. Socrates's reasoning upset the elder leaders so much that they held a trial to prosecute Socrates on the basis of being "a doer of evil, who corrupts the youth: who does not believe in the gods of the state, but has other new divinities of his own[2]."  A jury of Athenians found Socrates guilty and initially settled on a punishment of thirty minai, but the leaders of Athens continued to push for the death of Socrates and forced a vote from the Athenians for a stiffer sentence. He was finally sentenced to execution at the age of 71.  The following excerpt from Plato's Euthyphro,Apology,Crito,Phaedo describes the death of Socrates.

"He walked about and, when he said his legs were heavy, lay down on his back, for such was the advice of the attendant. The man who had administered the poison laid his hands on him and after a while examined his feet and legs, then pinches his foot hard and asked if he felt it. He said "No": then after that, his thighs: and passing upwards in this way he showed us that he was growing cold and rigid. And again he touched him and said that when it reached his heart, he would be gone....To this question he made no reply, but after a little while he moved: the attendant uncovered him: his eyes were fixed[3]"

       I believe that during that ancient time period there were probably many deaths caused by Hemlock. The majority of these deaths were probably caused by an overdose of Hemlock that was intended to be as a treatment for an ailment such as joint pain. From my reading on Hemlock it seems that a very slight overdose could cause significant pain and injury to the central nervous system. There are theories that Socrates was not killed by Hemlock but some other drug, but I believe Plato's description of the symptoms that Socrates endured provides overwhelming evidence that it was indeed Hemlock that killed Socrates. I imagine that Socrates' death was somewhat quick and painless due to the amount of Hemlock he ingested. The accounts of Socrates' trial and his death depict Socrates as a man who was not angry with other people but acquired many enemies due to his intelligence and influence on other people. One of his most popular quotes shows how his philosophies could have made him many enemies. In Plato's Apology ,which recounts the trial of Socrates,  Plato tells the story of a friend of Socrates asking an oracle if anyone was wiser than Socrates and the oracle said no. This led Socrates to try and find a man wiser than him and of course Socrates found men who believed that they were wiser than Socrates. But when they began to tell Socrates all of the things they knew and believed in, he came to the conclusion that these men truly thought that they knew everything that there was to know. The interaction with these supposedly brilliant men led Socrates to come to the conclusion that,
"he(Socrates) was the wisest in so far as he(Socrates) knew that he(Socrates) knew nothing." Philosophies such as this one led people to dislike Socrates and eventually led to his undoing.
Bibliography

1. Lindberg, David C./ The Beginning of Western Science (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1992)
2. Plato/ Apology
   
Translation by  Benjamin Jowett
3. Plato/  Pahedo
    Translated by Benjamin Jowett

4. Wikipedia, "Socrates", Wikipedia Free Encyclopedia,http://homepage.mac.com/kvmagruder/hsci/resources/bibliography.html

5.   W. Jeffrey Hurst, "Hemlock," Medician Antiqua
       Web-link: http://www.medicinaantiqua.org.uk/sa_Hemlock.html

Authors Notes:

I believe my secondary source by Jeffrey Hurst to be reliable because he has a very respectable background with a PhD,FAIC and is a clinical associate professor of comparative medicine at the Penn Stat-Geisinger Medical Center.
I used my sources to provide the background for my argument and to show a real life account of the effects Hemlock has on the human body.


Image 1
"The Death of Socrates" by Jacques-Louis David(1787)
Web Link: http://www.law.umkc.edu/faculty/projects/ftrials/socrates/socrates.HTM


Image 2
Portrait of Socrates
Origin: Roman (1st century)
Location:Louvre museum, Paris, France, MA 59
Web Link: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Image:Socrates_Louvre.jpg

OU Home | Disclaimer | Copyright | Equal Opportunity | OU Web Policy